What the numbers actually say
Let's start with the uncomfortable part. As a traffic channel, AI search is still small.
An analysis of a year's data from 100 websites with more than 145 million visits showed that for every 1,000 visits from Google's organic results, just over 6 came from ChatGPT. Google delivered 964 conversions. All AI chatbots combined delivered 36.
So if anyone tells you to move your budget from Google to AI search tomorrow, that doesn't match the numbers.
And then there's the other side. In two surveys, 62 per cent say they have bought a different brand from their usual one because of an AI chatbot. Among those who use chatbots when shopping, 81 per cent have dropped a purchase because of what the AI said. Both surveys were paid for by vendors, so take the numbers with a pinch of salt. The point still holds: if you're not in the answer, you don't lose a click. You get struck off the list in a conversation you never see.
For us, around 3 in 100 new enquiries since January 2025 have come via ChatGPT, and there have been more this year than last year. That's not many. They're enquiries from people who have already made up their minds before they get in touch.
So the right way to look at it isn't as a traffic channel. It's brand. An AI answer brings together what you've written yourselves, what others write about you and the coverage you've had into one recommendation.
The robots aren't the audience
Google itself says in its guidance on AI search that there are no extra requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode. No special optimisations. No new AI files.
What decides whether you make it into the answer is the content. When someone asks an AI a question, it breaks it down into a series of sub-questions, finds answers to all of them and writes a combined answer. The questions are also around three times as long as ordinary searches.
That means something concrete for you: you need answers to far more questions than before. Not ten pages about what you sell. Concrete answers to everything your customers might think to ask.
Freshness counts too. A vendor of AI visibility tools said at Web Summit that half of the content AI cites most is less than 13 weeks old. Those are their own numbers, and they match what we see with our customers.
Mentions carry the most weight
A study of 75,000 brands found that what correlated most closely with being mentioned in Google's AI answers was how often the brand was mentioned elsewhere on the web. Reviews, press and coverage.
That's PR. It can't be tracked click by click, and all serious brands work with PR anyway. This is where AI and branding meet, and it's why we treat AI visibility as a brand task rather than a technical one.
Four things you need to do
1. Create much more content, and answer the questions. Write down what customers ask about in sales meetings, in support and in e-mails. Each question is a page. Here's how to build it up in practice: content marketing. It's the cheapest effort you can make, and the one fewest people make.
2. Keep it fresh. Choose your 20 most important pages, and set a fixed date for when they get updated. A page from 2022 with correct information loses to a page from this year with the same information.
3. Build mentions. Get mentioned in the places your target audience reads. When anyone can create content with AI, the winners are the ones people know and trust. We've written about the four levers here: how to get your brand mentioned in AI answers.
4. Get the technical foundations right. Pages that can be crawled. Internal links. A cookie banner that lets you measure what you're allowed to measure. Text instead of images of text. Up-to-date information in Merchant Center and on your Google profile. Without that in place, you won't show up on Google or in an AI answer.
Measure the right things
This is where most people go wrong. A ranking in ChatGPT is a snapshot.
In one experiment, volunteers asked ChatGPT, Claude and Google's AI the same 12 questions almost 3,000 times. The chance of getting the same list of brands twice was less than 1 in 100.
So don't pay for a report showing your ranking in ChatGPT. Measure this instead:
- How often you're mentioned across many questions, not your position in one answer
- Searches for your name over quarters, not months
- Enquiries, and where they come from
- AI traffic set up as its own source in Google Analytics
And measure conversions in the first place. In the big analysis of 100 sites, 45 of them had no conversion tracking at all. Then there's no way of knowing whether anything works.
Four questions for your supplier
If you're offered GEO or AEO, ask these four questions:
- How will you get us into more answers? If the answer is tricks for the robots, schema hacks or special AI files, say no thanks.
- How much content do you create, and how often do you update it? That's where the work is.
- What do you do to get others to mention us? Without mentions, nothing happens.
- What do you measure, and when will we see it? If they can only show rankings, they're measuring the wrong thing.
How we do it
We treat AI visibility as part of the brand and the content, not as a separate technical discipline on the side.
We start by working out what you should be known for and which questions your customers ask. Then we build the content that answers them and keep it up to date. Our AI tools take care of the routine: they go through pages, find gaps in the content and catch technical errors. The specialists assess and decide, and you approve the changes.
We don't promise a ranking in ChatGPT. Nobody can. We work to get you mentioned more often, and to get more people asking for you by name.
Frequently asked questions about GEO and AEO
What's the difference between GEO, AEO and LLMO?
No real difference. They're three names for the same thing: being mentioned in the answers from AI search. We say AEO.
How much traffic comes from AI search?
Still very little. An analysis of a year's data from 100 websites with more than 145 million visits showed that for every 1,000 visits from Google's organic results, just over 6 came from ChatGPT. The value isn't in the traffic. It's in being part of the recommendation.
Is GEO the same as SEO?
Almost. What works is more content, better content and more mentions. It's SEO, just more of it. There's no evidence for tricks for the robots, schema hacks or special AI files.
How do you measure AI visibility?
By how often you're mentioned across many questions, by searches for your name over quarters, and by enquiries and where they come from. Not by a ranking in one answer.
Your next step
Write down the 20 questions your customers ask most often. Check whether you have a page that properly answers each of them. The gaps you find are your plan for the next quarter.
If you're unsure which gaps matter, get in touch.